Shouldn’t Trump be thanking Comey for going outside procedure right before an election just to say, “Clinton sure is sus” for no reason?
Idiocracy is sort of like the Left’s version of the Great Replacement Theory. And the underlying premise doesn’t work for the same reason that the Great Replacement Theory doesn’t work.
That being said, Idiocracy’s predictions have been scarily prescient. People are making dumber and dumber decisions. But it’s not because of dumb people having more children than smart people. It’s more due to economic inequality, parents failing to teach their children to think for themselves, people being exposed to more and smarter propaganda, and perhaps things like childhood malnutrition.
The core concept of it, effectively it is eugenics, IQ etc…
The real part of it is, it’s not eugenics, it’s education that’s hitting the spiral. Poorly educated people, keep getting convinced to make education less accessible and worse, leading to more poorly educated people, that vote harder on it, ad infinium.
Bottom line, religion and power structures have found education as their target to limit, and have been for decades.
I do agree the opening of idiocracy really presented some extreme “eugenics” vibes to it. Which also is kind of weird because the end of if basically presented the opposite. Where not sure in his mediocre knowledge starts pushing for education improvements, improving the culture etc… Not sure’s conclusion at the end was basically that everyone is ignorant not dumb, and society could gradually be fixed by actually trying.
The introduction may be confusing but it wasn’t advocating for eugenics, the movie intro can be viewed as dumb people raise their kids to be dumb, not that intelligence was passed down genetically. And you are correct, religion and power need uneducated people to maintain hegemony.
where I gotta disagree with you on their framing.
For starters, it’s talking evolution. A specific biological process about inherited genes.
“How did this happen? Evolution does not make moral judgments. Evolution does not necessarily reward that which is good or beautiful. It simply rewards those who reproduce the most.”
Next point is, it’s showing IQ scores. Fans of IQ scores, generally also believe in the studies that imply they are innate, heritable traits.
Sorry but am I completely missing something, is there one part in this intro that even once implies intelligence as, cultural, education, or really says anything other than “smart people have smart kids, if they have them”, “dumb people have dumb kids”.
Again I hold to the gist, it’s a comedy, not meant to be perfectly clear scientific thesis, but the speach from the narrator, is almost always that. even with the ending of “they gave birth to three children, the 3 smartest kids in the world”. “his vice president Frido took 8 wives and had 32 kids, the dumbest kids to ever walk the earth”.
It’s pretty insane that Trump’s being allowed to do this
Why won’t somebody do something
They got fired and replaced.
What are you up to tonight. Scrolling?
Ok and what are you doing
Pointing out to you how useless everyone here is. How the left is full of people saying that they’ll do something and who are pissed off every day but they can’t be bothered to create content, build networks or spread awareness. They think they’ll show up to some protest 3 cities away and that will somehow fix stuff because that’s what worked in the 70s. What are you doing, seriously what are you doing? Just trying to keep the status quo that’s working great currently, what are you trying to defend here?
This may be a groundbreaking idea, but people actually exist outside of lemmy and do stuff
But they don’t. The average leftist left all social media. It’s clear as day given that so much content is absent any left ideas. The reason people in all our lives all agree that Charlie Kirk was such a great guy is because people on the left doing exist in any significant way outside of a couple digital spaces. One of those is Lemmy. Go get a sample and start asking random people if they have social media accounts elsewhere anymore. Go ask people in your life if they’re aware of any of the ideas on the left. Go on any social media and see if you’re getting videos defending left wing principals or is it just toxic hate posts. The left abandon digital spaces and retreated to places like Lemmy.
what are you doing at the devil’s sacrement
The only people who have the formal power to do something think this is 100% awesome.
Ya fuck. I just wish like people could like work and organize towards civil action or something. If only there was a way. But they have money or something
They’re complicit
The grand jury indicted based on a massive lie which will fall apart in court.
As is expected when only one side of the story is allowed to be told. It’s also why grand juries don’t really matter. Any headline referring to one is generally click bait, since alot of people don’t know theyr basically just a pretrial checkpoint
Fuck this eugenics spouting movie that blames individual weakness over systemic evil.
It’s not eugenics, it’s evolution. Eugenics is intentional, the intelligent population in the movie dies off due to unplanned, natural ecological factors. Also, it’s a comedy, just chill out.
Intelligence is not a genetic trait. The claim that it is one is a myth used to perpetuate eugenics. It comes from the archaic claim that “black people are inherently less intelligent than white people” because “white people are genetically superior”.
It has nothing to do with evolution.
Also, the flimsy excuse “it’s just a joke” is simply that: an excuse.
Intelligence is not a genetic trait
Wait, where the hell did you get this idea? Racially? No, intelligence spans significantly from individual to individual regardless of race, but on that individual level, genetics have a significant impact on intelligence.
Not only that, but the movie makes no commentary on race whatsoever, throwing that in is solely your own addition.
Genetics absolutely plays a role, there’s a clear distinction between accepting reality and then turning around and using that to justify murder or racism.
