I’m talking about people who farm and need labor to survive, and placing that labor in the context that sometimes you can be left alone, have relatively little direct impact from colonialism or even capitalism, and that doesn’t make one’s labor somehow special or magical. You can do everything right and free from most trappings of capitalism and life can still be hard and suck.

Posts like this push some socialist farm worker fantasy, as if Soviet era propaganda of smiling peasants was how things were - I’ve lived like that. It’s not pleasant on average, which is why people leave those communities unless something specific keeps them there. It works as a method of basic survival of the species, but so does having 7 or 8 kids per woman to try and get 3 to reach adulthood so you can sell off one girl for the dowry payment.

I’m also talking about places where no French or English is spoken, where the currency they use isn’t even the one for the country where they live, and none of that changes the fact that rain-fed subsistence agriculture is backbreaking labor. There’s no one to blame but the Earth itself, and climate change on a long enough scale, but desertification of the Sahara has been taking place for thousands of years. Climate change is simply speeding up the inevitable, but population growth is making that worse. Trees only grow so fast, and they don’t grow fast enough for a village of 20 cook fires to suddenly expand to 50 cook fires in 20 years and not impact the environment.

Whatever, we’ll all end up experiencing it ourselves in the next 10 years or so anyway.