• 0 Posts
  • 59 Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: June 11th, 2023

help-circle
















  • Every major country that has ever gone down the communist road has ended up a dictatorship.

    Up until not too long ago, every democracy relied on slavery, disenfranchised large parts of the population, and eventually ended up a dictatorship. If you asked someone in like 1810 whether democracy could work, it’d be completely understandable if they pointed out all the horrible aspects of Greek and Roman “democracy”, American planations, colonialism and the Reign of Terror, and if they assumed all of these to be inherent to democracy.

    “Sure, the king isn’t perfect, but he’s surely better than Robespierre (who was inevitably succeded by Napoleon). And besides, great thinkers like Plato argued for a philosopher king – and that guy lived in a democracy, who would know better about all of it’s evils?”

    Yes, communism has failed in many respects so far.* The reasons for that are complex, include active sabotage by anti-communist states, but anyone who doesn’t genuinely and critically reflect it’s failures is (probably) doomed to repeat those mistakes.

    Assuming those are inherent and inevitable based on less than a hundred years of history is imho short sighted.

    *Some very early societies were probably kinda close to what we conceptualise as communism™ today, but applying the term is anachronistic.