Hi all. I recently got a Pixel 8, and it’s my first ever Android phone. I’m loving it so far and glad I switched over. One thing that’s honestly driving me crazy though is the photo picker. On iPhone it was easy to pick a photo directly within the Messages or any other app, either a recent one, a favorites one, or one from an album, with just a few taps. When I use the photo picker from within the Messages (or other app) on my Pixel, though, it feels incredibly convoluted. First it pulls up a grid of 5-ish recent pictures, followed by rows and rows of seemingly random pictures from the past 20 years. To get to my favorites, for instance, I have to tap on the folder icon, then tap the three dots, tap browse, tap Photos, tap Photos again, then tap favorites. Is this really how it’s supposed to work, or is there a setting I can change somewhere? I’ve double checked that Messages has permission to access all photos and videos. Thanks in advance for any help!
You must log in or register to comment.
I never use SMS to I was wondering what you were talking about, and now that I’ve tried Messages I’m absolutely appaled by the design of the file picker. I think Google stole Discord’s design, but somehow made it worse? A year ago, I would’ve said “try Signal for SMS” but that no longer works because of RCS fuckery. This is infuriating. I’m glad everybody is ignoring Google’s request to use this new image picker.
After a bit of testing, the best workaround I’ve found is clicking the “files” button to launch the normal (non-image-optimised) file picker. It should open a generic file browser, in which you have the option to filter images or videos, like so:
Tall media, click to expand
It still doesn’t exactly provide fast access to your favourites, but it skips two steps at least. Google Photos is in the “Browse files in other apps” shortcut when opening the generic file picker.
Alternatively, you could do things in reverse: open the picture you want to share, then use the share button to select a contact to send it to.
This stupid image picker doesn’t seem to be restricted to Google Messages, either. Apparently they’re recommending developers to use this screen in their apps, and they’ve backported this thing to older Android versions as well.
Thanks! Glad to hear I’m not the only one who is flabbergasted by this design, but kinda bummed it wasn’t just user error. I appreciate the suggestions for workarounds.
I’m guessing you moved images over from your iPhone to the Pixel? I’d have to imagine the timestamp data is incorrect or something after the transfer because they’re all listed in order from newest to oldest for me. If I want something from a specific image folder I just hit the folders button and each folder then lists them just the same. If you look at your image’s details in the Photos app are the dates/times for those images all pretty much the same?
Yeah, you’re right that that’s what’s going on. I realized it last night and I found a way to change the timestamp on all those photos. I haven’t done it yet but I’m hoping that will solve the biggest part of my problem.
I’m on a pixel 6 and in messages, I have a tile view of most recent created/modified photos, whether that’s download, camera, whatever folder.
For a specific folder of older images, I usually click into the camera with two taps of the power button and get into photos library that way.
I don’t know if that’s the best way, just how I get into all the folders if the photos are older
Yeah I think I’m just going to need to build muscle memory to do it that way instead. I think it’s especially not useful for me because I recently imported all of my photos from iCloud. A whole bunch of what shows for me are old engagement photos of me and my ex. 😂
Haha, rough.
Especially with a newer phone, it’s easy to have one app for every function without overloading the memory, so I’m sure if you look through different available photo apps there will be one where you can set a group of your favorite folders so you can just click straight into there
Couldn’t replace.
When I try adding a photo in messages I get a grid with a viewfinder (which is really cool and clever) and a few recent photos. Tapping folders brings up all the photos on my phone in chronological order. I can’t see though how to open Google photos from this screen to get non local photos.
Also in typical android I’ve never seen this set up on any other app.
Get GrapheneOS! I would love to have a Pixel8 (I guess) but dont yet. GrapheneOS is the best and most secure Android there is.
Why is there so much unrelated astroturfing in this community?
They do have a point. I am using the AOSP Messaging App and this issue doesn’t happen. I am able to browse and select multiple photos very easily. Google Messages is a better option because of RCS, but the AOSP messaging app seems to be better with photo selection.
but no one recommends using SMS so I guess the new photo picker layout is the way to go now
doubly weird suggestion for someone coming from iPhone for the first time
